MiP Insights Psychological Insights

The Comparison Trap: AI and Social Media

The Comparison Trap: AI, Social Media and the Impact on our Psychology

How is technology changing the way we think, communicate, relate and see ourselves?

Technology has become an increasingly influential part of our everyday lives. It is influencing the way we think, communicate, interact, access information, form opinions and understand the world around us. Its influence is difficult to deny or escape. It is also difficult to fathom the magnitude.

In particular, social media and AI (artificial intelligence) is rapidly changing and effecting not only what we do, but how we experience ourselves and our relationships with others. In many fundamental ways it is changing our psychological makeup.

Let’s do some unpacking.

We have always compared ourselves with others. And compared other things against each other too. It is a fundamental part of being human. Largely without knowing it we are always making comparisons. Such as the shapes, sounds, smells, images and colours etc from the world around us. And this been the case since birth. And it never stops.

This primal reaction allows us to absorb information. Information we then use to  try to make sense not just of the world but of ourselves and how we fit into it. This information collecting includes everything and everyone who inhabit the world with us. It is, as I mentioned, an important part of how we make sense of ourselves.

We do this through our senses – sight, smell, touch, sound and taste – which helps us identify and then notice differences and similarities. From here we form ideas about things and people, which we endlessly use to develop other thoughts. We are all constantly make comparisons about things, and we do this to make sense of and understand ourselves. For example, we notice someone with blond hair and compare that to our hair. Oh, mine is brown. Through such comparison we develop traits and impressions about ourselves, such as our abilities, appearance, achievements and relationships. Sometimes this inspires us whilst at other times it can leave us feeling less than ‘them’, and inadequate.

 

We are always gathering and comparing.

The world we live in is a drastically different and rapidly changing landscape. It is so remarkably different from the world you were born into. Whatever your age this is true.

Social media has made other people’s lives, achievements and apparent successes almost constantly visible to us. We are exposed to an endless stream of carefully selected images, opinions, lifestyles and personal milestones. It presents idealised visions of people, their world and their lives. These too can provoke inspiration but for many it also provokes more critical thoughts as we assess our worlds – rounded in every way – against these shaped and incomplete visions presented to us.

 

Social media: Comparing ourselves against someone else

Our natural impulse to compare ourselves with others has always been influenced by the world around us and the information available to us. Throughout history, the media has played an important role in shaping how we see ourselves, other people and the society we live in. From pamphlets and newspapers to magazines, radio, cinema, television and the news, each new form of communication has introduced us to different ideas, images and representations of how people live, look, behave and succeed.

Every form of media influences and shapes our expectations and aspirations. From propaganda to Film Noire, Holly/Bollywood to radio shows, lifestyle magazines to TV shows, content writers, screenplay and script writers, they have presenting us with their view of the world. They gave presented us ideas of what is beautiful, views on status, success and lifestyle, whilst also delivering impressions and perceptions about genders, stereotypes and relationships too.

Through these lenses we have looked at public figures, celebrities, fictional characters and other people. And simultaneously, we have used these views as reference points, sometimes consciously, but often sub-consciously or unconsciously soaking up the information and applying it to our lives, our dreams and our world.

The power of such influence is immeasurable because with the primal urge to compare we are constantly assessing and reassessing our understanding of what is desirable, acceptable or considered successful etc.

In this sense, the media has long provided standards against which we might measure ourselves and our own lives.

 

But what has changed more recently is the additional availability, scale, speed and frequency of such exposure. Social media has accelerated and elevated this process to new heights, allowing other people’s lives, opinions, and choices etc, to be seemingly all around us, all of the time. And as we compare and view their achievements and apparent successes – using ourselves as the barometer – this can feel overwhelming. The volume of comparative visions are like endless waves of information crashing in.

Unlike earlier forms of media, social media these days does not simply present images and stories created by a select few who wrote, broadcast, published or advertised their views and products. Now, social media allows millions of people to share their own views. Their content offering an almost continuous stream of personal experiences, opinions, lifestyles and milestones.

We are not simply observing others as they go about their lives. We are often seeing carefully selected moments, edited images and constructed versions of their reality. People share the parts of their lives they want others to see, while much remains unseen. It is like an iceberg with only the tip visible above the surface. What lies beneath is the rest including difficulties, disappointments, uncertainties and ordinary experiences that make up everyday life.

 

 

AI: A new benchmark for comparison

And then AI came along.

Artificial intelligence introduces another dimension to this experience. We are no longer simply comparing ourselves to other people. We are increasingly exposed to technology that can write, analyse, create, communicate and solve problems at remarkable speed. Even though we know AI is not really human, interacting with it evokes human responses and emotions in us. We have begun assessing and comparing ourselves with machines.

And this is raising some very interesting and important psychological questions.

Such as:

  • What happens when we compare ourselves beyond other human beings?
  • How are we judging our own intelligence, creativity, productivity and capabilities against something that operates so differently from us?
  • And what happens to our sense of identity and self-worth when the benchmarks against which we measure ourselves keep changing?

 

Artificial intelligence introduces another different kind of comparison. It presents us with something that can perform tasks traditionally associated with human intelligence and ability. It can produce written work, analyse information, generate ideas, create images, solve problems and communicate in ways that can appear remarkably human. And it can do it in a flash. Which is most unlike humans.

This raises questions that go beyond convenience or technological progress because as AI becomes increasingly quicker and more capable, we may begin to question our own abilities more.

Understandable questions and fears have arisen. What was previously seen as individual skills and resources might now seem less valuable, useful and important. After all, if a machine can write an article in seconds, what does that mean for someone whose profession involves writing? If it can analyse complex information, generate ideas or produce creative work, how will this affect those who have spent years learning, training and developing such skills?

For some people, AI may be an exciting tool that supports learning, creativity and productivity. It can help people explore ideas, overcome obstacles and achieve things they might otherwise find difficult. But for others, its capabilities may provoke uncertainty, anxiety or a sense of being left behind.

There is an important personal psychological dimension that deserves further attention too. Our abilities are often closely connected to our identity. What we know, what we can do and the skills we have developed contribute to how we see ourselves and how we believe others see us. Our work, expertise and creativity can provide a sense of purpose, competence and self-worth.

When technology begins to perform tasks that we have traditionally regarded as uniquely human, it can challenge some of our assumptions. We may find ourselves questioning whether our knowledge is sufficient, whether our skills remain relevant or whether the things we have worked so hard to develop still distinguish us. It can leave us anxiously wondering if we are ‘good enough’.

This is a very human deduction. One which almost every human alive will have faced as we are sensitive and emotionally driven creatures.

The computer is not. AI does not think, experience or understand the world in the same way as we do. Its ability to produce convincing responses or impressive results does not give it an ego boost. It’s programmers and developers perhaps get. The investors and stockholders probably do. And that’s the point. They are people with their own interests and motivations who may not also hold in mind the impact of their investment upon other people. It is easy for these dynamics to be overlooked and forgotten.

It is also easy to forget that our perceptions may be or can be different than others. That people can be effected and suffer as a result. It is easy to forget that by creating super intelligence people will potentially feel inadequate as a result and worry about being left behind, rejected and abandoned.

Finding ourselves in a rapidly changing world

Perhaps the greatest challenge is not the technology itself, but how we respond to it and the expectations it creates.

As human, we want to feel valued, accepted and that we have something meaningful to contribute. Yet constant exposure to other people’s achievements, idealised images and increasingly capable technology can leave us questioning our own abilities and feeling that we are somehow falling behind.

We need to remember that our value is not measured solely by what we achieve, how productive we are or how quickly we adapt. It is also found in our relationships, experiences, creativity, emotions and capacity to connect with others. These are important parts of being human, not qualities to be measured against a machine.

There is also a responsibility for those developing and introducing new technologies to consider their wider human impact. Progress should not come at the expense of people’s confidence, identity or psychological wellbeing.

We can embrace change, admire others and make use of technology without allowing comparison to determine how we feel about ourselves.

Technology will continue to shape how we think, communicate, work and relate. The challenge is to ensure that, along the way, we don’t lose sight of our own humanity.

In a world increasingly shaped by comparison, how do we hold on to our sense of self and recognise our own value?

mip therapy psychological support psychotherapy psychodynamic cbt